Pricing your menu is one of the most important decisions you'll make as a restaurant owner. Price too high, and customers walk away. Price too low, and you're leaving money on the table—or worse, losing money on every dish you serve.
This article is part of our comprehensive resource: The Ultimate Guide to Food Costing and Menu Pricing.
The good news? There are proven formulas and strategies that successful restaurants use to find that sweet spot. In this guide, we'll walk through everything you need to know about pricing your menu items for maximum profitability.
The Food Cost Percentage Formula
The foundation of menu pricing is understanding your food cost percentage. This is the ratio of what you spend on ingredients to what you charge customers.
Food Cost % = (Ingredient Cost / Menu Price) x 100
Most restaurants aim for a food cost percentage between 28% and 35%. Fine dining can go lower (25-30%), while fast-casual might run higher (30-35%). The key is consistency across your menu.
To calculate your ideal menu price, flip the formula:
Menu Price = Ingredient Cost / Target Food Cost %
For example, if your pasta dish costs $4.50 in ingredients and you want a 30% food cost:
$4.50 / 0.30 = $15.00 menu price
Calculating Your True Ingredient Costs
Before you can price anything, you need to know exactly what each dish costs to make. This means calculating:
- Direct ingredientsEvery component that goes into the dish, measured precisely down to the ounce
- Waste factorAccount for trim, spoilage, and prep loss (typically 5-15% depending on the ingredient)
- Portion costsConvert bulk purchase prices to accurate per-serving amounts
Pro Tip: Update your ingredient costs monthly. Supplier prices fluctuate, and small increases can quietly erode your margins over time.
Tired of calculating food costs manually?
DishTrack automates recipe costing so you can focus on what you do best—cooking.
4 Menu Pricing Strategies That Work
- Cost-Plus PricingThe most straightforward approach: calculate your costs and add a markup. If you want a 30% food cost, multiply ingredient costs by 3.33. Simple, consistent, and easy to maintain.
- Competition-Based PricingResearch what similar restaurants charge for comparable dishes. You don't have to match competitors, but understand where you stand and justify any premium.
- Value-Based PricingPrice based on what customers perceive the dish is worth, not just your costs. Signature dishes can command premium pricing.
- Psychological PricingUse pricing tricks that influence perception: $14.95 feels cheaper than $15.00, removing dollar signs, and anchoring with high-priced items.
Common Menu Pricing Mistakes to Avoid
Even experienced restaurant owners make these errors:
- Undervaluing labor: Your prices need to cover more than just ingredients. Factor in prep time, cooking time, and plating.
- Ignoring portion creep: If cooks start adding extra portions "to be generous," your food costs silently increase.
- Racing to the bottom: Competing on price alone is a losing game. Focus on value instead.
- Set it and forget it: Review and adjust prices at least quarterly, or whenever ingredient costs shift significantly.
Menu Engineering: Strategic Item Placement
Menu engineering combines pricing with psychology. Categorize your items into four groups:
- StarsHigh profit, high popularity. Feature these prominently on your menu.
- PlowhorsesLow profit, high popularity. Consider raising prices or reducing portions slightly.
- PuzzlesHigh profit, low popularity. Improve descriptions, placement, or staff recommendations.
- DogsLow profit, low popularity. Remove or completely reinvent these items.
Analyze your menu mix regularly. The goal is to shift customers toward high-profit items while maintaining satisfaction.
Getting Started with Menu Pricing
Start by calculating the true cost of your top 10 best-selling items. You might be surprised—some of your most popular dishes could be your least profitable.
From there, apply the food cost formula to each item and compare your current prices to the calculated ideal. Adjust gradually; sudden large price increases can shock regular customers.
Remember: pricing isn't a one-time exercise. Build a system to track costs, monitor food cost percentages, and adjust prices as needed. Your margins will thank you.
Price Your Recipes with Confidence
DishTrack helps food businesses calculate accurate costs and set profitable prices—automatically.
Get Started FreeLearn More About Food Pricing
Explore our guides to become an expert at pricing your food products: